PART A

Section I

• Reviewer’s Name :
• E-Mail :
• Manuscript Number : ARJ-16-0050
• Title :
• Authors :
• Date Sent To Reviewer :
• Date Expected From Reviewer :

PART B (Reviewer Only)

Section II : Comments per Section of Manuscript :

• General comment :
• Introduction :
• Methodology :
• Results :
• Discussion :
• Bibliography/References :
• Others :
• Decision :

SECTION III - Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent), (2 = Good), (3 = Fair), (4 = poor)

• Originality :
• Contribution to the Field :
• Technical quality :
• Clarity tf presentation :
• Depth of research :

SECTION IV - Recommendation: (Kindly Mark With An X)

• Accept as is :
• Requires minor corrections :
• Requires moderate revision :
• Requires major revision :
• Submit to another publication such as :
• Reject on grounds of (Please be specific) :

SECTION V : Additional Comments

• Please add any additional comments (Including comments/suggestions regarding online supplementary materials, if any) :